Dissertation defense outcomes: passing and revisions

Dissertation defense outcomes in the US, including passing with minor or major revisions, why failure is rare, and next steps.

Last updated November 20, 2026

A dissertation defense ends with a decision from the committee about whether the dissertation and its defense meet the standard for the PhD. In the United States, most defenses result in a pass, often with revisions to complete before final submission.

Terminology and categories vary by university, but most use a similar range of outcomes.

Common outcomes

Typical outcomes include:

  • Pass with no revisions: the dissertation is accepted as it stands. This is relatively uncommon.
  • Pass with minor revisions: small changes, such as clarifications and corrections, usually checked by the advisor. This is among the most common outcomes.
  • Pass with major revisions: more substantial changes, such as additional analysis or rewriting sections, sometimes reviewed by the full committee.
  • Defense not passed or postponed: the committee requires significant further work and a second defense. This is rare.

What happens after the decision

The committee usually explains the required revisions, either at the defense or in writing. The candidate completes them, often with support from their advisor, and the committee or advisor signs off. The degree is conferred once the final dissertation is deposited and approved by the graduate school, usually on the next official graduation date.

Why outright failure is rare

In US programs, advisors and committees generally review drafts before agreeing to schedule a defense, and are unlikely to let a candidate defend work that is not ready. Problems are therefore usually addressed before the defense rather than at it.

International comparison

In the UK, outcomes after the viva are framed as “corrections,” with categories such as minor corrections, major corrections, and “revise and resubmit,” and a lower degree can be awarded instead. Some European systems award grades or honors, such as cum laude, which are not used in the US.

Common misunderstandings

Revisions are often taken as a negative result. In practice, they are a normal part of the process and reflect the committee’s role in improving the final dissertation.

It is also commonly believed that major revisions mean failure. These outcomes still lead to the degree in the large majority of cases once changes are made. More serious situations are covered in What happens if things go wrong during your PhD.

Get one practical PhD tip a week

The PhD Place newsletter: advice, real stories, new funding, and the link to our free weekly writing group. Free, and you can unsubscribe anytime.

Related guides

Update cookies preferences